wcaleb’s avatarwcaleb’s Twitter Archive—№ 8,536

  1. 1. Thinking about cigarillos, cigarette taxes, and how the history of the Reconstruction Era casts light on cases like #EricGarner's.
    1. …in reply to @wcaleb
      2. On the one hand, @AdamSerwer and others are right to note with outrage conservative commentary on #EricGarner as fruit of high taxes.
      1. …in reply to @wcaleb
        3. On the other hand, Reconstruction historians like Foner have shown how postwar Black Codes used regressive taxes to control black people.
        1. …in reply to @wcaleb
          4. In Radical Reconstruction, black political power managed to shift tax burden to white landholders, creating a progressive tax structure.
          1. …in reply to @wcaleb
            5. White supremacist "Redeemer" governments in 1880s & 1890s immediately shifted taxes & fines back onto the black poor as tools of control.
            1. …in reply to @wcaleb
              6. There's a parallel b/w the so-called "hog laws" that sentenced blacks to hard labor for "theft" & heavy policing for stolen cigarillos.
              1. …in reply to @wcaleb
                7. And likewise a parallel between regressive sales taxes in Redemption-era Black Codes & taxes that fall heaviest on disadvantaged.
                1. …in reply to @wcaleb
                  8. "it is hard to get farther from the point than arguing the cause of Garner's death was cigarette taxes..." @AdamSerwer/540340745023291392
                  1. …in reply to @wcaleb
                    9. … UNLESS you add that state-sanctioned control of black Americans has historically often taken the form of things like cigarette taxes.